Idea #24: Convert Main Avenue to a Pedestrian Mall

The Church Street Marketplace in downtown Burlington, Vermont was originally conceived in 1958 and constructed in 1980. In the time since, it has been recognized time and again as a prime example of good urban design for public space. It’s managed by a public commission. (PHOTO:

I must admit that this is an idea that’s been gnawing at me for some time. It struck me last June during Terrain’s Bazaar, which was taking place on Wall Street between Main Avenue and Spokane Falls Boulevard, then grew on me during my time in Germany this past fall. In many of Europe’s cities, the central avenue in the city center is closed to vehicles. The result is a much more pedestrian-centered experience with a vibrant, exciting city life. What if we took this same logic and applied it to downtown Spokane?

Let’s convert Main Avenue between Lincoln Street and Bernard Street into a pedestrian mall.

At first glance, this may seem like a radical idea. Why would we want to convert six city blocks into a limited access, pedestrian-only experience? Why would we want to restrict vehicular access? The answer, of course, is vibrancy. The on-street experience would be greatly enhanced by the addition of new street trees, new public gathering places and amenities, and pedestrian-specific features. Imagine farmers’ markets, food trucks, flash mobs, and handicraft vendors all gathering in one place downtown. Imagine winter carolers and summer gallery openings. And imagine it all being outside of the control of the Cowles family, which recently proposed to take 17 feet of public right of way at the Wall Street pseudo-“pedestrian mall” for a “mystery national retailer.”

The prospect is tantalizing. But it would require a concerted effort at programming. A public commission or non-profit board a la the Seattle Center’s management structure or that of Portland’s Pioneer Courthouse Square would work well. And we’ll have to work on finding solutions to the traffic problem (especially cross-traffic on Stevens and Washington) as well. But we can do it. We can replace lost parking, improve traffic flow downtown, and build a vibrant community all at the same time. So let’s get behind a pedestrian on Main Avenue. Let’s make it happen.

What do you think? Do you support the idea for a pedestrian mall on Main Avenue? Do you think it could spur investment along that street, where parking lots have languished undeveloped for years and years? What would you like to see programmed at a pedestrian mall downtown? Share your thoughts below in the comments, on Facebook, on Twitter, or in person. We love to hear from you.

6 thoughts on “Idea #24: Convert Main Avenue to a Pedestrian Mall

  1. Seattle Center is a department of the City of Seattle and funded and managed as such, though there is an advisory board. Despite that, most of the attractions are privately owned concessions with admission fees and the grounds themselves can be closed for private events requiring admission. It’s overly optimistic to think there’s a solution outside financial influence – especially where private property would be impacted.

  2. I LOVE this idea. When my husband and I lived in Brownes Addition, we always loved walking downtown. We visited NYC in 2012 and were impressed with the Times Square walkable mall and thought Main Street would be perfect for that! Why stop at Bernard? Why not go to the Community Block?

    • Biggest issue would be the cross-streets at Bernard and Stevens, but certainly it would be cool to see some sort of solution to extend it all the way down there. I’d be interested in seeing some usage statistics for Main Avenue. Lots of potential here!

  3. Good idea, but a little long.. I’d say to Stevens at most…unless there’s a better way to route traffic. Stevens/Washington is a busy flow through downtown. Cutting that off might cause traffic flow problems.

    • Agreed. It’d be interesting to find alternative routes. Alternatively, perhaps those major cross-streets could persist but with pedestrian enhancements at the intersections. It wouldn’t be a full mall in those areas, but it would be miles better than the existing conditions.


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s